Volunteer counts for Merry Memorabilia 2011

Whew, that was a lot harder than I thought it would be! Mainly because there was an exception to the rules format allowed that created a grey area open to some interpretation. It wasn't quite as easy as "this is absolutely a point and this one is not". I tried as much as possible to give the benefit of the doubt while working in the grey area while trying to be fair to all the other participants, too. This, of course, leads me to make my best opinion in some instances and where I did that I will note it. I did this equally for all, so I put comments even on the lower overall scores. There can be other opinions, too, and if they need to be debated, this is the place to do it. NDS reserves the right to the final decision. Overall though, the change in score wasn't so great as to change place order, with one possible exception.

That being said here is what I found:

721 points Narfi Hungry Willem

481 points Tzepelea Tzepu Geri

377 points Tetania Sailing Arcanum

346 points Raven Lunchbox Palehorse This is the exception. He claimed Crunk Sharks as different mobs instead of maturities (see Entropedia) lowering his claim. I also found 6 points that I couldn't validate, 1
was a double post, 1 Zomhatten I didn't find, the others were missing info without Tracker backing.

287 points zoran drhegi kenth

240 points John Lockside Lock

126 points Paavo PP Pesusieni

120 points Jack The Ripper Russel

115 points Linus Zip Lindström I thought splitting the difference of his unclaimed Tracker proofs fair (+5)

107 points George Ace Skywalker I counted Nomad as different from Outlaw. If they are the same mob then +9 points

100 points leene leene fr

71 points SD Farmer Trojan -1 from claimed, math error, 13 globals = 58 points

60 points Jabez JAG Groove

46 points Paul Crystal Thunder There were more things not in these screenies than in, which is usually considered excessive manipulation to the shot. I allowed for most but 2 of the Zomhattens I couldn't do.
There are 10 more points here if approved by NDS.

5 points John Connor GUNNER +1 point than claimed

5 points Kobar Kobar Bar I didn't allow for the Dreamer point mentioned in the post without a screenie as there was statement of not even competing at the time it happened

3 points Szilard Skeezer Aszkenaze

1 point Amber Blastie Knightley

N/A Corina Carny Haynes Name is entered on the hunting roster but I didn't find any hunting globals

N/A Shaman Wizard Legend Didn't submit a single valid screenshot per the rules, so I couldn't count any of them regardless of whether they are on Tracker or not. This was not a Tracker event.
Sorry, in my count I understand that Tracker was only allowed to verify the odd bugged screenie, not to replace the time and position stamps.


That was some crazy hunting, good show everyone!

Now to start the Mining.......this could take awhile........

Wow, a lot of work. Thanks again Ketch. Yes, you're correct, I had no hunting globals. My mistake if I implied I was submitting anything for the hunting event. Boss coming, tabbing back to Excel

lol, np, don't get caught !

Originally Posted by Ketch

346 points Raven Lunchbox Palehorse This is the exception. He claimed Crunk Sharks as different mobs instead of maturities (see Entropedia) lowering his claim.

In my opinion the different sharks are just different maturities as stated on Entropedia.
Mob is Crunk Shark and maturities are: Coral Hustler, Reef Eater, Tooth Assassin.

Originally Posted by Ketch

107 points George Ace Skywalker I counted Nomad as different from Outlaw. If they are the same mob then +9 points

In my opinion this is correct, Nomad is not the same mob as Outlaw.
Only NDS would really know how it is stated in their DNA but but it is how I play with Zombies
Again see Entropedia, the different Zombie mobs that belong to the Biker family are: Zombie Biker Prospect, Zombie Biker Enforcer, Zombie Biker Nomad, Zombie Biker Outlaw.

Originally Posted by Ketch

N/A Corina Carny Haynes Name is entered on the hunting roster but I didn't find any hunting globals

Aah yes correct, as Carny said.
She posted her entry for mining in the hunting thread that is why I got it wrong, I moved that now.

Originally Posted by Ketch

N/A Shaman Wizard Legend Didn't submit a single valid screenshot per the rules, so I couldn't count any of them regardless of whether they are on Tracker or not. This was not a Tracker event.
Sorry, in my count I understand that Tracker was only allowed to verify the odd bugged screenie, not to replace the time and position stamps.

I totally agree on this one. If no timestamps at all then its not ok, there are more then one other person who missed this and thus couldn't/didn't enter the competition because of this. Sorry Legend but it wouldn't be fair to the others who thought they couldn't enter cause they missed it.

Bigdaddys huntng scoreboard.

Narfi Hungry Willem Total = 721

Tzepelea Tzepu Geri Total = 481

Tetania Sailing Arcanum Total = 377

Raven Lunchbox palehorse Total = 332

zoran drhegi kenth Total = 287

John Lockside Lock Total = 240

Paavo PP Pesusieni TOTAL = 126

Jack The Ripper Russel TOTAL = 120

Linus Zip Lindström TOTAL = 110

George Ace Skywalker Total = 107

leene leene fr TOTAL = 92

Jabez JAG Groove TOTAL = 63

Paul Crystal Thunder TOTAL = 57

SD Farmer Trojan TOTAL = 37

Kobar total = 5

John conner GUNNER TOTAL = 5

Szilard Skeezer Aszkenaze TOTAL = 3

Amber Knightly = 1

Ok i got some scores diffrent, but in same order. Me and ketch both agreed on the shark and zombies. Also Legend did not do time stamp. If any1 want to double check the 1,s that me and ketch differ on please do. The list of winner still the same

I think you guys are correct. I asked ND about it during the event and this is what he posted in the thread,

Originally Posted by NEVERDIE

this is a good Question, for the sake of this event, if a Mob has a different name, then it is is a different mob...

So the Code Demons and Cyber demons are seperate mobs as are the prison mobs etc...

There are different kinds of Zombies too.

In the past we named each of our maturity levels to make them more interesting.. But in most cases i belive those names are replaced with Levels.

So for the sake of this event, if the mob has a different name then it is a different mob

So it was my understanding that the zombies were counted as separate mobs, and that since sharks are all 'crunk shark' + maturity then they are considered a single mob. If they are counted separately, then my score would need to be lowered as well.

U guys missed the special rule where all my globals are worth 5 times more points.......

Crap that still means Narfi won XD

Very good of you to volunteer. Well done all winners!

Grats to the preliminary winners

The event was great fun

I agree because a Pop Dragon Stalker is the same as a Pop Dragon Young for the sake of mob type. Crunk Sharks use different names for their maturity, similar to Aurlis being Chasers, Soldiers, and such. I don't believe anyone regards them as a different mob. So, that's why I counted the Crunk Sharks the same, especially in light of the Entropedia listing for them.

Originally Posted by narfi

I think you guys are correct. I asked ND about it during the event and this is what he posted in the thread,



So it was my understanding that the zombies were counted as separate mobs, and that since sharks are all 'crunk shark' + maturity then they are considered a single mob. If they are counted separately, then my score would need to be lowered as well.